Stealpad › Hayward, CA › 94546
Condos for sale in 94546
ZIP 94546 covers in Hayward and Castro Valley. 5 condos ($398,000–$500,000), each given a Deal Score vs. recent Hayward sold comps. 2 are priced below market — sorted best deal first.
68Good value
21239 Gary #206
$499,000
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,393 sqft · $358/sf
HOA $733/mo · Fl 2 · 72d · 20% below mkt
⚖️ Adjusted valueFairly pricedasking is 4% under fair value
Model fair value · 2 sold comps · ±5%$530,512
vs model fair value · size · beds/baths · age · HOA · location−6%
Condition · Avg / verify in person0
Price history · ≈4% below its peak+2%
✅ Positives
- On market 72 days → some leverage
- Garage parking
⚠️ Cons
- HOA $733/mo
🚩 Red flags
—
Price history (this unit)
Trough $499,000 May 26, 2026Now $499,000Peak $520,000 May 12, 2026
Current list price is 4% below its peak · +0% above its trough.
- May 26, 2026 — Price Changed $499,000
- May 12, 2026 — Listed $520,000
- May 11, 2026 — Coming Soon $520,000
Description
No description captured.
67Good value
21103 Gary Unit 318A
$475,000
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,100 sqft · $432/sf
HOA $703/mo · Fl 3 · 71d · ~at market (+2%)
⚖️ Adjusted valueFairly pricedasking is 3% under fair value
Model fair value · 12 sold comps · ±5%$500,686
vs model fair value · size · beds/baths · age · HOA · location−5%
Condition · Avg / verify in person0
Price history · ≈5% below its peak+2%
✅ Positives
- On market 71 days → some leverage
- Upper floor (fl 3)
- In-unit W/D
- Garage parking
⚠️ Cons
- HOA $703/mo
🚩 Red flags
—
Price history (this unit)
Trough $150,000 Mar 28, 1995Now $475,000Peak $498,880 Jun 6, 2019
Current list price is 5% below its peak · +217% above its trough.
- Apr 15, 2026 — Listed $475,000
- Apr 15, 2026 — Price Changed $475,000
- Apr 15, 2026 — Coming Soon $480,000
- Sep 12, 2019 — Sold (MLS) $461,000
- Sep 12, 2019 — Sold (Public Records) $461,000
- Jun 6, 2019 — Listed $498,880
Description
No description captured.
64Fair price
21109 Gary Dr #220
$459,000
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,041 sqft · $441/sf
HOA $710/mo · Fl 2 · 121d · ~at market (+4%)
⚖️ Adjusted valueFairly pricedasking is +2% over fair value
Model fair value · 12 sold comps · ±5%$465,417
vs model fair value · size · beds/baths · age · HOA · location−1%
Condition · Avg / verify in person0
Price history · ≈2% below its peak+3%
✅ Positives
- On market 121 days → strong negotiating leverage
- In-unit W/D
- Garage parking
⚠️ Cons
- HOA $710/mo
🚩 Red flags
—
Price history (this unit)
Trough $125,000 Sep 20, 1989Now $459,000Peak $470,000 Mar 24, 2026
Current list price is 2% below its peak · +267% above its trough.
- May 18, 2026 — Price Changed $459,000
- Mar 24, 2026 — Listed $470,000
- Aug 4, 2013 — Sold (MLS) $281,000
- Aug 2, 2013 — Sold (Public Records) $281,000
- Jul 12, 2013 — Listed $269,000
- Jun 29, 2001 — Sold (MLS) $265,000
Description
No description captured.
54Fair price
21103 Gary Dr Unit 307D
$500,000
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,025 sqft · $488/sf
HOA $710/mo · Fl 3 · 30d · 15% above mkt
⚖️ Adjusted valueFairly pricedasking is +5% over fair value
Model fair value · 12 sold comps · ±5%$489,993
vs model fair value · size · beds/baths · age · HOA · location+2%
Condition · Avg / verify in person0
Price history · ≈2% below its peak+3%
✅ Positives
- Upper floor (fl 3)
- In-unit W/D
- Garage parking
⚠️ Cons
- HOA $710/mo
- Photos look dim — verify light in person
🚩 Red flags
- HOA rising ~12%/yr in this building ($473/mo in 2022 → $733)
Price history (this unit)
Trough $169,500 Aug 31, 1994Now $500,000Peak $510,000 Jun 23, 2026
Current list price is 2% below its peak · +195% above its trough.
- Jul 20, 2026 — Price Changed $500,000
- Jun 23, 2026 — Listed $510,000
- Jul 7, 1998 — Sold (Public Records) $170,000
- Aug 31, 1994 — Sold (Public Records) $169,500
Description
No description captured.
48Priced high
21062 Gary Dr #102
$398,000
1 bd · 1 ba · 815 sqft · $488/sf
HOA $656/mo · Fl 1 · 35d · 15% below mkt
⚖️ Adjusted valueOverpricedasking is +10% over fair value
Model fair value · 73 sold comps · ±5%$371,680
vs model fair value · size · beds/baths · age · HOA · location+7%
Condition · Avg / verify in person0
Price history · at/near its all-time high+3%
✅ Positives
- In-unit W/D
- Garage parking
⚠️ Cons
- HOA $656/mo
- Ground floor
🚩 Red flags
—
Price history (this unit)
Trough $100,000 May 14, 1992Now $398,000Peak $398,000 Jun 18, 2026
Current list price is 0% below its peak · +298% above its trough.
- Jun 18, 2026 — Listed $398,000
- Jun 18, 2026 — Listed $398,000
- May 14, 1992 — Sold (Public Records) $100,000
Description
No description captured.
| Price ↕ | Deal ↕ | Address ↕ | Bd ↕ | Ba ↕ | SqFt ↕ | $/sf ↕ | Vs mkt ↕ | Value (cond.-adj) ↕ | Fl ↕ | HOA ↕ | HOA% ↕ | Built ↕ | DOM ↕ | Rent ↕ | 🚉 BART mi ↕ | ☀️ Photo light ↕ | Trough→Now→Peak ↕ | ✅ Positives ↕ | 🚩 Flags & cons ↕ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $499,000 | 68 | 21239 Gary #206 | 2 | 2 | 1,393 | $358 | 20% below mkt | Fairly priced | 2 | $733 | 1.8% | 1992 | 72 | $2,976 | 7.7 mi | ☀️ Bright | -4% pk · +0% tr |
|
|
| $475,000 | 67 | 21103 Gary Unit 318A | 2 | 2 | 1,100 | $432 | ~at market (+2%) | Fairly priced | 3 | $703 | 1.8% | 1993 | 71 | $2,976 | 7.8 mi | ☀️ Bright | -5% pk · +217% tr |
|
|
| $459,000 | 64 | 21109 Gary Dr #220 | 2 | 2 | 1,041 | $441 | ~at market (+4%) | Fairly priced | 2 | $710 | 1.9% | 1981 | 121 | $2,976 | 7.9 mi | ☀️ Bright | -2% pk · +267% tr |
|
|
| $500,000 | 54 | 21103 Gary Dr Unit 307D | 2 | 2 | 1,025 | $488 | 15% above mkt | Fairly priced | 3 | $710 | 1.7% | 1993 | 30 | $2,976 | 7.8 mi | 🌥️ Dim | -2% pk · +195% tr |
|
|
| $398,000 | 48 | 21062 Gary Dr #102 | 1 | 1 | 815 | $488 | 15% below mkt | Overpriced | 1 | $656 | 2% | 1980 | 35 | $2,335 | 7.9 mi | ☀️ Bright | 0% pk · +298% tr |
|
|