3 bed Rentals in Hayward, CA
33 active listings, each measured against what the Zillow rent index says a home of that size costs in its own ZIP. 5 are asking at least 8% under it.
33 listings31 scored5 under marketmedian asking $3,800
Pins are coloured by Rent Deal Score — green good, amber fair, red overpriced, grey unscored. Crowded areas collapse into a neutral blue bubble showing how many are there; zoom in to split it. One pin per address, so a building with several units listed shows them all in one popup. Tick Only this area to narrow the list to what is on screen as you pan.
$2,600/mo 25% under market
84Great dealhigh confidence
rent gap +30 · size +6 ($1.2/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 2,163 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🔆 Average light$1.2/sqft
$2,700/mo 26% under market
84Great dealhigh confidence
rent gap +31.2 · size +5 ($2.15/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,254 sqft · Hayward 94545
Model market rent $3,625/mo for a 3 bed in 94545
🌑 Dim / darker$2.15/sqft
$2,500/mo 20% under market
75Great dealhigh confidence
rent gap +24 · size 0 (no sqft published) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 1 ba · Hayward 94542
Model market rent $3,120/mo for a 3 bed in 94542
🚉 ~24 min walk · Hayward🌑 Dim / darker
$3,250/mo 10% under market
66Good valuehigh confidence
rent gap +12 · size -0.4 ($2.91/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,117 sqft · Hayward 94545
Model market rent $3,625/mo for a 3 bed in 94545
🌑 Dim / darker$2.91/sqft
$3,200/mo about right (-7%)
66Good valuehigh confidence
rent gap +8.4 · size +6 ($1.73/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 4 ba · 1,853 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🚉 ~17 min walk · Hayward🔆 Average light$1.73/sqft
$3,300/mo 8% under market
62Fair pricehigh confidence
rent gap +9.6 · size +1.2 ($2.7/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (2d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence · held at good by the ±3pt noise band
3 bed · 2.5 ba · 1,220 sqft · Hayward 94546
Model market rent $3,606/mo for a 3 bed in 94546
🚉 ~13 min walk · Castro Valley🌑 Dim / darker$2.7/sqft
$3,300/mo about right (-4%)
59Fair pricehigh confidence
rent gap +4.8 · size -0.2 ($2.9/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 1.5 ba · 1,136 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🌑 Dim / darker$2.9/sqft
Solstice Apartments
$3,275/mo about right (-6%)
58Fair pricehigh confidence
rent gap +7.2 · size 0 (no sqft published) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🚉 ~19 min walk · South Hayward🔆 Average light4 units available
$3,575/mo about right (-1%)
57Fair pricehigh confidence
rent gap +1.2 · size +1.6 ($2.64/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,354 sqft · Hayward 94546
Model market rent $3,606/mo for a 3 bed in 94546
🚉 ~23 min walk · Castro Valley🌑 Dim / darker$2.64/sqft
$3,400/mo about right (-1%)
52Fair pricehigh confidence
rent gap +1.2 · size -2.2 ($3.18/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 1 ba · 1,070 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🌑 Dim / darker$3.18/sqft
$3,295/mo about right (-5%)
50Fair pricehigh confidence
rent gap +6 · size -6 ($3.87/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 851 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🚉 ~10 min walk · South Hayward$3.87/sqft
$3,495/mo about right (+0%)
46Priced highhigh confidence
rent gap +0 · size -3.2 ($3.34/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence · held at fair by the ±3pt noise band
3 bed · 1 ba · 1,047 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🔆 Average light$3.34/sqft
$3,400/mo about right (-1%)
45Priced highhigh confidence
rent gap +1.2 · size -6 ($4.25/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 1.5 ba · 800 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🌑 Dim / darker$4.25/sqft
$3,800/mo 9% over market
40Priced highhigh confidence
rent gap -10.8 · size -1.4 ($3.05/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,245 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🔆 Average light$3.05/sqft
$3,800/mo 11% over market
40Priced highhigh confidence
rent gap -13.2 · size +4.6 ($2.21/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2.5 ba · 1,720 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🌑 Dim / darker$2.21/sqft
$4,000/mo 10% over market
39Priced highhigh confidence
rent gap -12 · size +2 ($2.59/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2.5 ba · 1,546 sqft · Hayward 94545
Model market rent $3,625/mo for a 3 bed in 94545
🌞 Bright$2.59/sqft
$3,700/mo about right (+6%)
36Priced highhigh confidence
rent gap -7.2 · size -5.8 ($3.7/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (2d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,000 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🌑 Dim / darker$3.7/sqft
$3,900/mo 14% over market
35Priced highhigh confidence
rent gap -16.8 · size +0 ($2.87/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 3 ba · 1,361 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🚉 ~2 min walk · Hayward🌑 Dim / darker$2.87/sqft
$3,995/mo 10% over market
32Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -12 · size -5 ($3.57/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (2d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,119 sqft · Hayward 94545
Model market rent $3,625/mo for a 3 bed in 94545
🌑 Dim / darker$3.57/sqft
$3,895/mo 13% over market
32Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -15.6 · size -1.4 ($3.07/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,270 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🌑 Dim / darker$3.07/sqft
$4,200/mo 21% over market
31Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -25.2 · size +4.4 ($2.22/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2.5 ba · 1,891 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🔆 Average light$2.22/sqft
$4,250/mo 17% over market
31Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -20.4 · size +3 ($2.45/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,736 sqft · Hayward 94545
Model market rent $3,625/mo for a 3 bed in 94545
🔆 Average light$2.45/sqft
$4,250/mo 22% over market
28Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -26.4 · size +2.8 ($2.47/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2.5 ba · 1,718 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🚉 ~16 min walk · South Hayward🔆 Average light$2.47/sqft
$4,100/mo 19% over market
28Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -22.8 · size +2 ($2.57/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 3 ba · 1,595 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🚉 ~7 min walk · Hayward🔆 Average light$2.57/sqft
$4,200/mo 22% over market
24Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -26.4 · size -1.4 ($3.05/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 3 ba · 1,375 sqft · Hayward 94541
Model market rent $3,434/mo for a 3 bed in 94541
🚉 ~2 min walk · Hayward🔆 Average light$3.05/sqft
$4,500/mo 29% over market
24Overpricedmed confidence
rent gap -34.8 · size +3.2 ($2.41/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (4d since the listing changed) · x0.8 for med confidence (the model runs low by 24% at this rent)
3 bed · 2.5 ba · 1,866 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🚉 ~7 min walk · South Hayward🌞 Bright$2.41/sqft
$4,200/mo 35% over market
23Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -36 (capped at 30%) · size +6 ($1.94/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2.5 ba · 2,168 sqft · Hayward 94542
Model market rent $3,120/mo for a 3 bed in 94542
🔆 Average light$1.94/sqft
$4,200/mo 35% over market
21Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -36 (capped at 30%) · size +4 ($2.29/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2.5 ba · 1,831 sqft · Hayward 94542
Model market rent $3,120/mo for a 3 bed in 94542
🌑 Dim / darker$2.29/sqft
$5,000/mo 38% over market
19Overpricedmed confidence
rent gap -36 (capped at 30%) · size -6 ($3.88/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x0.8 for med confidence (the model runs low by 24% at this rent)
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,290 sqft · Hayward 94545
Model market rent $3,625/mo for a 3 bed in 94545
🌞 Bright$3.88/sqft
$5,000/mo 44% over market
18Overpricedmed confidence
rent gap -36 (capped at 30%) · size -6 ($4.13/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +0 (1d since the listing changed) · x0.8 for med confidence (the model runs low by 24% at this rent)
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,210 sqft · Hayward 94544
Model market rent $3,482/mo for a 3 bed in 94544
🔆 Average light$4.13/sqft
$4,250/mo 36% over market
15Overpricedhigh confidence
rent gap -36 (capped at 30%) · size -5.8 ($3.7/sqft vs $2.87 typical) · sitting +3 (10d since the listing changed) · x1 for high confidence
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,150 sqft · Hayward 94542
Model market rent $3,120/mo for a 3 bed in 94542
🌑 Dim / darker$3.7/sqft
$5,999/mo
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,328 sqft · Hayward 94541
No verdict. Asking far above the index for this ZIP and size. A gap that large is usually something we cannot see from the listing — a different unit type, a stale post, a fee structure — rather than a real premium.
🌑 Dim / darker$4.52/sqft
$1,200/mo
3 bed · 2 ba · 1,700 sqft · Hayward 94541
No verdict. Asking 0.3x the typical 3 bed rent across the region. That far from its size cohort a listing is usually a different product — a whole house, a penthouse, a furnished unit — and the model is measurably weakest at the extremes, so there is no verdict.
🚉 ~6 min walk · Hayward🌑 Dim / darker$0.71/sqft